Inquiry elevates Japan to silver, Britain drop to bronze

Louis+Smith+Olympics+Highlights+Day+3+ImEpaSTFSO2l

This evenings Men’s Team Final at the North Greenwich Arena was incredible. I have never seen anything like it. Coming towards the end of the last rotation, it was clear that China had redeemed themselves from their awful qualifying competition to claim their second consecutive Olympic Team gold medals. It was also clear that should Japan not make any mistakes, they would be picking up silver with Great Britain and Ukraine fighting for bronze. The results sure came down to the wire. Great Britain knew a medal was attainable.

Kristian Thomas followed Daniel Purvis who nailed a beautiful stylish routine to earn scores of 15.433 and 15.533 respectively. Combined with Max Whitlock’s 15.133, GB secured the top overall floor score. Reigning 3 time All Around World Champion took to Pommels as Thomas’ score was announced, the crowd erupted yet Uchimura kept his cool. It was only at the last few seconds of the routine as Uchimura set himself up to dismount that something went wrong. Did he fall? Did he begin the dismount and then fall? He didn’t fall, per say but did he do a dismount? A score of 13.466 flashed up for the Japanese gymnast. The competition was over. Great Britain began celebrating their silver medal whilst the Ukraine cheered and were thrilled with their bronze medal whilst China continued to smile and Chen Yibings eyes teared up with joy as a result of retaining their Olympic Team title.

It was then announced that Japan had submitted an inquiry into Uchimura’s score. The judges conferred for 10 minutes. Whilst the crowd got louder, “booing” in disbelief. The verdict was in, those of us at home watching on television received the news before those inside the arena. The inquiry had been accepted and after a lengthy deliberation between judges, Uchimura had been awarded .700 onto his D score. An air of disbelief was almost tangible from the arena through my television screen at home. The addition of .700 awarded to Uchimura elevated Japan into silver position and knocked Great Britain to bronze, with Ukraine believing they were Olympic Team bronze medalists for 15 minutes. A shame.

Journalist Nick Zaccardi revealed the media communication that was presented to those in the Press Tribunes:

As Justin commented on the Full Twist Facebook page:

As outstanding of a gymnast Uchimura is, this just isn’t right. That was not a medal-clinching worthy performance. Silver medal was robbed from Great Britain.

I agree, Uchimura was not flawless in this performance. If this had been Louis Smith’s Pommel Routine then I could understand but with this routine, no. Uchimura himself showed signs of utter disappointment upon landing knowing that the medal had slipped through his hands due to this performance.

This is a shame for the sport, for GB and does not reflect so well on Japan. Alas, as per yesterdays controversy of Jordyn Wieber who was unable to qualify for the All Around final due to the two per country rule, there are rules in this sport, rules which gymnasts, coaches and judges must abide by. One of those rules is that a score can be questioned but you cannot question another gymnasts score, only your own. So to answer those who have asked – no, Great Britain could not have queried why Uchimura was awarded the .700.

I cannot wait to see a video of this when it appears online and I hope that a MAG judge could possibly break the routine down and show exactly where the marks were taken. It would enlighten many a gymnastics fan.

What is your take on this? I am disappointed that it left many leaving the Men’s Team Final with a bad taste in their mouth. At the end of the day, Great Britain still made the podium and achieved an astonishing result. This team has come a long way in the last few years. The importance of a medal to the sport of gymnastics in Britain, regardless of colour, cannot be overstated. No GB Men’s team has previously come close to a result of this magnitude in the modern days of gymnastics. Yes, Great Britain had the silver taken from them by Japan but let us not forget about the Ukraine, who were Olympic bronze team medalists for a mere 10 minutes on Monday July 30th 2012.

Image via Ghetty Images.

7 Comments

  1. This is China’s second consecutive team gold. Japan won in 2004.

  2. gymfan says:

    USA sucks, no medal. Britain should be happy for getting a medal, they were NEVER that good. Pity for Ukrain

  3. Milogymfan says:

    First, they didn’t give him 0.7 but 0.5 as he did in fact perform a dismount – a very bad dismount, but he landed on his feet.
    Second, every other nation would have done the same thing.
    Third, he should have gotten the right score in the first place, so it’s absolutely not his fault. You have to blame the judges and perhaps the people responsible for publishing the final scores so quickly. Japan questioned the score immediately.
    And forth, this quote doesn’t show a good understanding of the sports of gymnastics:
    “As outstanding of a gymnast Uchimura is, this just isn’t right. That was not a medal-clinching worthy performance. Silver medal was robbed from Great Britain.”
    You don’t win your medal only on the last apparatus. Take a look at the wonderful work of the Japanese on HB or on SR or on PB (events on which they finished 2nd overall behind CHN). That’s where they won a lot more points than the british team or Ukraine.
    In my opinion, Japan still did a wonderful job after they lost one teammate. The wrong judging isn’t their fault. It was a bad situation for everyone involved and it shouldn’t have happend in the first place. And I feel sorry for Great Britian and especially for the Ukraine. But in the end, that’s the right podium.

  4. Milogymfan says:

    Sorry, my first comment is wrong. You are absolutely right: They did give him 0.7, not 0.5.

  5. Grant Thorn says:

    It’s incredible that the dismount was given. There was no support through the turn. As great a gymnast Uchimura certainly is, this was not his best work. He was falling from the pommel horse, did not show support in his turn, did not cross the horse as he was supposed to and made the best of a fall from the apparatus. The Difficulty judges, one of whom was japanese himself, made the right call and the apparatus supervisor agreed with their assessment. No dismount was awarded. If it hadn’t been Uchimura then the decision would have remained. Three international experts were in accord. Where do the MTC get 0.7 from. If a C dismount was awarded, that would have satisfied a partial dismount requirement for 0.3 and 0.3 for a C, which would have been 0.6. Had they awarded a D dismount, which it certainly was not, then that would have been 0.5 full dismount requirement and 0.4 for a D resulting in 0.9. It was never a D. The additional 0.7 is an impossible increment.
    The judges were entirely correct in their original assessment and every international judge reviewing the video cannot help agree with their colleagues who were charged with evaluating yesterday’s routine.
    Ukraine lost out on a medal yesterday and Britain dropped from silver to Bronze. There is no other sport where the judges or referees are overruled in this manner. A disservice to gymnastics was done yesterday.

  6. Ying says:

    Shame on Japan! Can you believe a team can still win the silver medal with 4 major errors?! Britain and Ukraine deserve their medals! They did an oustanding team final! Especially Ukraine. It broke my heart to watch them pray desperately and still get knocked off the podium. Can’t wait to see Uchimura and Japan get battered in the following competitions.

Trackbacks for this post

  1. Video: Uchimura's Dismount | Men's Team Final - Full Twist

Leave a Comment

Powered by WordPress | Deadline Theme : An AWESEM design

  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • YouTube